Becoming a Generalist

In the context of rural ministry, being a generalist is not just an advantage. It is almost essential. The role of a rural pastor involves a broad range of responsibilities that go far beyond the traditional expectations of preaching and pastoral care. Pastor McVey suggests that a rural pastor should adopt the mindset of a farmer. Farmers are a “jack of all trades” who have to handle a range of challenges. 

You might see a farmer as the epitome of a generalist. Their daily responsibilities are vast and varied, requiring them to possess a wide range of skills. As McVey points out, a farmer is not just involved in planting and harvesting. They are also mechanics, accountants, traders, and sometimes even carpenters and painters. This breadth of expertise allows them to maintain their operations independently, adapting to whatever challenges arise.

For a rural pastor, adopting this generalist mindset means being prepared to engage in numerous activities beyond preaching and teaching. This can include anything from helping repair the church building to organizing community events or even assisting with local agricultural tasks. By acquiring the versatility of a farmer, pastors can build trust and rapport within their communities. They can demonstrate their commitment and willingness to serve in whatever capacity is necessary.

Competency is measured differently in a rural setting than in urban or suburban environments. In business and city contexts, competency often means being a specialist. You excel in a particular area and contribute that expertise to a larger team. However, in rural areas, competency is closely tied to your ability to perform a number of different tasks effectively.

A rural pastor must be able to navigate the diverse needs of a congregation, which often requires a hands-on approach. For instance, a pastor might need to lead a Bible study in the morning, visit a sick person in the congregation in the afternoon, and help fix a broken fence in the evening. This kind of adaptability is crucial in rural ministry, where resources are limited and professional services are not always readily available.

One of the key aspects of being a generalist in rural ministry is the willingness to “get your hands dirty.” This phrase, while metaphorical, also has a literal application. Physical labor is highly valued in agrarian communities, and pastors who are seen actively participating in the physical work of the community gain respect and credibility.

McVey's anecdote about helping to feed cattle upon his arrival in Lamont, Kansas, underscores this point. Despite his lack of training in agricultural tasks, his willingness to engage in such activities demonstrated his commitment to the community. This hands-on involvement helps pastors build strong, relational connections with their congregation, showing that they are not above the everyday tasks that define rural life.

During community events or church gatherings, a rural pastor might find themselves setting up tables, preparing food, or cleaning up afterwards. These ordinary tasks are critical for the smooth operation of community activities. By willingly taking on these roles, pastors demonstrate their dedication to the community and their readiness to serve in any capacity.

This willingness to serve extends to times of crisis. Rural communities often face unique challenges, such as natural disasters, economic hardships, and social isolation. In such times, a pastor’s ability to provide practical assistance can be invaluable. This assistance can range from organizing relief efforts, offering emotional support, or coordinating resources. This level of involvement reinforces the pastor's role as a pillar of the community and a source of stability and support.